New Diet Study
A new study published this month in the Journal of the American Medical Association concluded that the Atkins Diet, high protein and low carbs, produced more weight loss among a sample of obese women than did the Ornish, LEARN, and Zone diet plans. However, while the women on the Atkins diet lost a few more pounds over the year their weight loss was statistically insignificant from the other plans. While heart health factors did improve in the Atkins diet, one researcher commented, "lower-carbohydrate diets look like a good option, but if you consider them, eat olive oil and fish rather than butter and sausage."
One danger of the low carb high protein diets is kidney stress and bone loss. Protein is very acid forming in the body and acid ash or residue is very hard on the kidneys. The South Beach diet, not included in the study, may be the most balanced diet. The diet works in phased timeframes. The two are are more restrictive promoting weight loss to your desired level while the third phase is designed to maintain your desired weight. Research has shown that in the short term dieting can work, but many people who diet eventually regain their lost weight. The best approach to weight loss seems to be lifestyle changes that result in a healthy diet and exercise program. Dr. Deb's class on March 29 looks at the relationship between Proteins, Fats and Carbs in the healthy diet.